1.

Administrator

1845-1879

Rev. Michel Mollory, O.M.I.

2.

Administrator

1847

Rev. Terrence Wade Smith

3.

Administrator

1883-1900

Rev. J.S. Sloan

4.

Residing Pastor

1900-1907

Rev. Thomas John. Brownrigg

5.

Residing Pastor

1907-1915

Rev. Thomas Patrick Fay   

6.

Residing Pastor

1915-1932

Rev. John Cunningham

7.

Residing Pastor

1932-1946

Rev. Phil Cleveland Harris

8.

Residing Pastor

1946-1952

Rev. Leo Lesage

9.

Residing Pastor

1952-1954

Rev. J. Lorne Reynolds

10.

Residing Pastor

1954-1957

Rev. Vincent Hogan

11.

Residing Pastor

1957-1963

Rev. John Michael Beahen.

12.

Residing Pastor

1963-1966

Rev. John Alexander Whelan

13.

Residing Pastor

1966-1970

Rev. Victoras Skilandzinus

14.

Residing Pastor

1970-1974

Rev. Robert Martineau

15.

Residing Pastor

1974-1976

Rev. Terence Sloan

16.

Residing Pastor

1976-1982

Rev. Francis McEvoy

17.

Residing Pastor

1982-1988

Rev. Ross Finlan

18.

Residing Pastor

1988-1994

Rev. Francis Scott

19.

Residing Pastor

1994-1999

Rev. Michael Wright

20.

Administrator

1999-2000

Rev. Gordon C. MacLean

21.

Residing Pastor

2000-2003

Rev. Thomas Bluger

22.

Residing Pastor

2003-2009

Rev. C. Ross Finlan

23.

Residing Pastor

2009‑

Rev. Virgil Amirthakumar